Yes, I realize it's a scarce note, as revealed by the Charlton catalogue ($400 in Good) --- congratulations on reeling it in against strong opposition!.
The question I should really have asked in my original post is the following: "At what grade does a rare note become essentially worthless, or worth only its face value?"
About a year ago I auctioned on eBay a fragment from an issued example of the ultra-rare Union Bank of Newfoundland $50 1889 note. It was the middle one-third and was in an attractive EF condition (similar in shape to the scan below). The complete note catalogues at $15,000 in VF but the one-third fragment realized only about $50 ..... ouch !! (I guess I should have waited a year or two longer before auctioning it!)
Also, we should remember that there are several different types of "rarity" and that these appeal to different types of collector. For example, some notes are rare as a basic type (e.g., the Newfoundland note below), some notes are of a common type but have a rare date (e.g., the Dominion Bank $50 1901), and some notes are of a common type but have a rare signature (e.g., the Dominion Bank $5 1925 with Nanton signature).
{http://images.andale.com/f2/115/106/3433819/2007/5/28/1179895357864_0.jpg}
« Last Edit: May 28, 2007, 01:04:32 pm by Ottawa »
Logged
" Buy the very best notes that you can afford and keep them for at least 10 years. " (Richard D. Lockwood, private communication, 1978).