CPM Forum

Special => Insert & Replacement Notes => Topic started by: 50monarch on February 09, 2010, 05:35:33 pm

Title: Replacement $5 Note???
Post by: 50monarch on February 09, 2010, 05:35:33 pm

On eBay (270528108642).  How is it possible that this is a replacement banknote?  It's even PMG graded and noted as a replacement.  Judging by the number of times the seller uses "Replacement" in the description, I'm thinking he/she knows it is not a replacement note. 

I guess my question is, how can a Company that grades banknotes for a living not know what is and is not a replacement banknote?  Maybe Brent has a spare Charlton Catalogue that he can send to PMG.  ;D

Title: Re: Replacement $5 Note???
Post by: friedsquid on February 09, 2010, 08:22:23 pm

This is the what the seller has on his description.....I guess this says it all ???

Quote

WE OFFER A 7 DAY NO QUESTIONS ASKED RETUN POLICY ON ALL UN-GRADED "RAW' ITEMS.THERE ARE NO RETURNS ON 3rd. PARTY GRADED ITEMS

Title: Re: Replacement $5 Note???
Post by: alvin5454 on February 10, 2010, 05:04:13 am

I notified the seller ac couple days ago that this was not a replacement. Here's the response:

HI SIR,
I KINDA HAVE TO LIST THE NOTE AS PMG HAS ON THIER HOLDER.THEY ARE THE LARGEST GRADING COMPANY IN THE BUSINESS,BUT I WILL LOOK INTO THIS TOMORROW.I ADMIT I KNOW LITTLE IF NOTHING AT ALL ABOUT CANADA CURRENCY.ITS JUST A COLLECTION WE PURCHASED AND THE PMG POPULATION REPORT AS WELL AS HERIATAGE AUCTIONS AS WELL AS THE PMG HOLDER ALL STATE ITS A REPLACEMENT ??? I WILL SEE WHAT I CAN FIND OUT.I'AM SURE YOU KNOW MORE ABOUT IT THAN I DO.
THANKS,GOD BLESS,BILL

Listing has not been withdrawn or adjusted.....

Title: Re: Replacement $5 Note???
Post by: friedsquid on February 10, 2010, 06:31:18 am

And this was my response from the seller

Quote

THANKS,I JUST WENT BY WHAT THE HOLDER SAID.
GOD BLESS

Funny thing is that the holder doesn't say all of the other stuff he has to say about the note in his description....
Maybe I should bid and start my own PMG holder collection of flaws  ;D

Title: Re: Replacement $5 Note???
Post by: gonkman on February 10, 2010, 03:29:30 pm

Well its cancelled now..

Looks like PMG Likes Canadian Money...  All the notes he has for auction are GEMs..

Sometimes I think PMG Justs has 3 Stamps... 65,66,67.

They randomly selects one of the 3 for each note being graded.  :)

Sorry... shots at PMG are so easy.  Too easy..