Assuming the A is a prefix letter, not a check letter, it appears that you are describing a Barclays Bank $5 signed Bruce-Borden.
As a collector, the way I would approach a problem note is in this fashion:
Would I prefer this note or a problem-free note in EF condition (or VF, or G or whatever), until I get to a point where I feel the same toward a problem note or a lower grade problem free note.
That will guide me in what price to pay.